Justin Upton in Pinstripes? Probably not but this is me in the role of GM. Image: Jennifer Stewart-US PRESSWIRE

Where the Market Could be for AZ D'Backs' Justin Upton

Let me be clear:  I do not want to see star right fielder Justin Upton traded.  I feel it would be a big mistake for the Arizona Diamondbacks to trade a 25-year old player with bundles of talent and five full years of experience at the Major League level.  Did I mention he is under contract for three more years and that the team is a year removed from a division championship?  Perhaps a year from now or even 2014 I could change my mind.  But not now, not when some tinkering this offseason can return the D’Backs to postseason play.  Plus, if they wanted to go to a full transition mode, they can trade Upton after next season and not resign Aaron Hill and Jason Kubel.  That’s a discussion for another day.

Now that we are pretending to play general manager, here are three landing spots for Mr. Upton.

New York YankeesThere is a potential opening in right field with Nick Swisher probably not back and perhaps Ichiro Suzuki as well.  Our cohort Joe F over at yanksgoyard proposed the Yanks get Upton for Catcher Gary Sanchez, 2B David Adams, SS Eduardo Nunez and RHP Brett Marshall.  It is a prety good deal when you consider that Sanchez is the Yanks’ #1 rated prospect according to mlb.com.  The problem is that the D’Backs are locked into Miguel Montero at catcher and Nunez, while an excellent hitter, is a butcher in the field.  A more realistic trade for Arizona would be Upton for starting pitcher Phil Hughes, lefty reliever Boone Logan and outfield prospect Tyler Austin.  Logan would be the lefty in the bullpen the team is seeking and Hughes would strengthen the rotation particularly if the team decides to start Tyler Skaggs and Trevor Bauer at Triple A Reno..  Austin is New York’s #3 rated prospect and can realistically start in right field in 2014.

Texas RangersWith super prospect Jurickson Profar making his MLB debut last season, rumors are swirling that the Rangers would be looking to deal shortstop Elvis Andrus. Right field seems to be locked up in Texas with Nelson Cruz but trading for Upton could be a hedge for the Rangers in case they lose Josh Hamilton.  Arizona’s primary every-day need is at shortstop and Andrus is still only 24 and signed through 2014.  A trade sending Upton to the Rangers for Andrus, outfielder Craig Gentry and lefty pitcher Martin Perez would fill needs for both teams.

Pittsburgh PiratesOne does not normally associate the Bucs and the acquisition via trade of a big name player.  Pittsburgh could make an exception in this case for Upton as his contract calls for slightly less than $10 million this season before jumping over $14 million in 2014 and 2015.  An outfield combination of Upton in right and Andrew McCutchen in center would make for one fearsome duo.  The Pirates’ #3 rated prospect is shortstop Alen Hanson who is probably at least two seasons away but has the makings of a superstar. Recently added Cliff Pennington would have to hold down the fort for the D’Backs until Hanson is ready.  Also to be included for Arizona would be Garrett Jones who would be asked to return right field and left handed pitcher Justin Wilson, the Pirates’ #7 rated prospect in their system.

Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter @venomstrikes

Follow me on Twitter @ltj41 and at http://clearthebases.net


Next Diamondbacks Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:10at San Diego PadresBuy Tickets

Tags: Arizona Diamondbacks Justin Upton New York Yankees Pittsburgh Pirates Texas Rangers

  • Noah Dougherty

    I agree. His market value would have to be really high to deal him considering his contract remaining/age/$$. While I’m not really convinced we’re going to see anything better than what we’ve seen, there’s no point in getting trigger happy and sending him off and watching him flourish in another city…not yet anyway.

  • John Smith

    The Phillies seem interested too, and with his brother. It is the city of brotherly love after all. The flyers did it with the schenn brothers, I wouldn’t be shocked if the Phillies tried to get both of the Upton brothers. They have a ton of pitching prospects and if I remember correctly the Diamondbacks are seeking SP this offseason. Let me know if you think this is also a possible location for Mr. Upton

  • http://www.facebook.com/doughertyjeremy Jeremy Dougherty

    Great post Thomas. It’s an interesting option, trading Upton, and one I’m not really excited about. “In Towers we Trust” has been my mantra since he came onboard with the Dbacks so I’m sure he wouldn’t peddle Justin off for some guys that wouldn’t garner some significance,even if that came in 3 years or whatever. But ti would have to be significant and while some of these options are appealing, I’m extremely nervous that Upton is going to pull a David Ortiz and hit 28-30 years old and start mashing .300/45/140 and then we’d all be in the backyard setting up the noose. He’s so close to being great, so young and reasonably cheap under contract for several more years. It’s a risk I think I’d rather take that he’s “subpar” for what we expect the next couple years than see him get traded and explode. Especially if we’re getting Penningtons in return…

    Side note…can you imagine Upton in NYY? He might just crumble given how upset he got throughout this season when we were booing him at home games. The NY crowd would chew him up there.