Skip to main content

Diamondbacks get firm Blue Jays trade vindication with surprise Gabriel Moreno Silver Slugger win

Winner!
ByAdam Weinrib
New York Yankees v Arizona Diamondbacks
New York Yankees v Arizona Diamondbacks | Chris Coduto/GettyImages

The NL West is the epicenter of the catching universe these days. One season after Hunter Goodman of the Colorado Rockies surprisingly swiped a Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Award away from Will Smith of the Los Angeles Dodgers, Gabriel Moreno has won the honor tonight, halting a Goodman repeat bid in its tracks. Smith, somehow, wasn't even a finalist, missing too significant a portion of the regular season with an injury. Moreno was more than happy to fill that void.

Or maybe it was Goodman filling the void, considering Moreno and his ridiculous 6.7 bWAR, .311 average and 16 home runs set an impressive new standard, despite the absence of an All-Star nod this summer for the D-Backs star.

And so the light shines not only on Moreno in the desert, but also on the semi-controversial 2023 trade that sent him to Arizona in exchange for more-than-meets-the-eye outfielder Daulton Varsho. Varsho's defense, occasionally outwardly spectacular but often hidden by his incredible range. At the time, the deal appeared to be a need-for-need, win-win swap. That's probably how it'll go into the record books. After all, Moreno's Diamondbacks and Varsho's Blue Jays both made the World Series during the trade's afterglow (2023 and 2025).

Revisiting Gabriel Moreno, Daulton Varsho trade after DIamondbacks catcher's Silver Slugger win

But time has marched on. Varsho is gone, traded to the Houston Astros in the middle of a down season in Toronto. He's a free agent, and the Jays probably feel their initial investment was enough. Moreno? He ascended to a new plane in 2026 and is an essential piece of Arizona's future. He's under team control for two more seasons, and as FanSided's MLB Insider Robert Murray hinted on tonight's Silver Slugger winner reveal show, a new contract with Moreno should be a priority this offseason ... and likely will be.

Tonight, Diamondbacks fans can revel in the reality that they pulled off a coup for their core when they acquired Moreno. Varsho never quite hit the heights he was projected to; his power dissipated over the years, and he's now mostly known for bashing the ball into the ground with the bases loaded and the World Series-winning run at third base. IKF was a toe too slow for immortality.

Moreno, on the other hand, is a Silver Slugger at a loaded position in MLB's most loaded division. If the D-Backs are going to make it back to the postseason, either by Wild Card or extreme upset, it'll happen on his sizeable shoulders.

Add us as a preferred source on Google